Occupy Toronto Plans Have Ominous Tone

Pedestrians are reflected in a glass building as they walk alone a security fence on Front Street in Toronto, Thursday, June 24, 2010, as the security fencing is in place around the Metro Toronto Convention Center for the upcoming G8 and G20 Summits. (AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster)

Organizers behind a planned Canadian version of the “Occupy Wall Street” protest will meet today at a University of Toronto campus, according to a blog site for Occupy Toronto.

One troubling sign has been a demand from protest organizers that Toronto Police not repeat what many believe were harsh and unnecessary tactics during last year’s G20 protests.

While unprecedented numbers of protesting citizens were detained by police, scenes of destruction played out on city streets that shocked many watching the mayhem unfold on live television.  Scenes of burning police cars could be repeated if so-called “Black Bloc” anarchists take to the streets during what promises to be a prolonged downtown rally.

City authorities have suggested that should protestors occupy public space for a lengthy period they may be subject to health and safety inspections.  The police have remained tight lipped on their plans, except to say that they have appropriate measures in place.

Similar overtures were made by both protest groups and police officials last year, leading up to the G20.

For downtown business owners and corporate executives, there is cause for alarm.  A review of security processes and procedures would be appropriate, according to Wellesley Consulting Services consultants.

Bookmark and Share

Global Defence Company Provided Summit Communications

The entire communications system used by the RCMP and affiliated police and public safety agencies during the G8/G20 summits in Ontario last month were provided by a subsidiary of EADS Defence & Security, according to a news release issued yesterday.

PlantCML, a Temulca, Calif.-based communications company owned by EADS, was responsible for the sophisticated secure radio and digital communications system used up to and during the summits, an advanced open architecture, IP-based trunked system called CORP25.

CORP25 is a system that integrates with the APCO “Project 25″, or P25, radio system designed by Motorola and which is already in use by the Province of Ontario.

According to EADS, the CORP25 system served a “mission critical role” and handled over 264,000 radio transmissions during the summit security operation.

The system took seven months to implement, used a multimedia P25 logging system to track all radio messages, and incorporated Motorola XTS 2500 digital trunked portable radios for front line personnel.

The cost of the radio system was not disclosed in the news release, however approximately 2,500 radios were deployed, including both portable and base station systems.  Each XTS 2500 portable radio typically costs in the $5,000-$10,000 range depending on configuration and accessories, meaning the cost of radio equipment alone could easily have been in the $20-25 million range.

Bookmark and Share

G20 Violence Highlights Value of Emergency Planning

The Toronto G20 Summit provided a crystal clear lesson in the value of emergency planning and having a “72-hour kit” ready at home, work, or your car.

For two days, much of the downtown core of Toronto was under a form of roving seige, where protestors and police would clash, then disappear, and clash again somewhere else.

Much of the pre-summit focus was on protecting the world leaders in attendance, and ensuring the security fences surrounding the meeting location was not breached.  But, outside of the “wire” it was every person, and every business, for themselves.

The well-known downtown mall, the Eaton Centre, was locked down Saturday afternoon.  All TTC subways south of the Bloor-Danforth line were stopped by 2 p.m.  The PATH network was completely closed, isolating the various office and commercial buildings of the financial district, while police cruisers burned in intersections and groups of black-clad anarchists merrily roved around looking for the next easy hit.

On the grand scale of disaster planning, the G20 protest violence and mayhem did rank quite low.  Water supplies remained untouched, the fires were relatively small and limited to a few abandoned police cars.  Electricity kept going, as did telephone and cellular networks.

But many businesses that were open were suddenly forced to lock themselves down when groups of thugs roamed too near.  Queen west restaurants were busily serving meals to patrons when the action rolled past their windows, smashing up bank ATMs and vandalising coffee shops along the way.

Several condos located close to the security fencing were well within an area sterilized by police from protestors.  Those residents that had not left town were few, and they essentially had to stay put in their buildings while the police went about clearing the streets of thugs and mischief-makers.

For those businesses and residents in and near the scenes of police and protestor clashes, burning cars, and window-smashing, a stocked 72-hour kit could have provided security and assurances during the unfortunate blightedness.

The safest solution would have been to shelter-in-place.  This means communicating with loved ones to advise them of your whereabouts and intentions, and ensuring you have the ability to survive for the period of shelter without reliance on city services – who were busy dealing with roaming bands of thugs and various burning cars.  Telephone and wireless services were relatively unaffected, and Internet access is usually available somewhere in the downtown core.  Satellite phones are still relatively expensive, but can be an option to have in place for emergencies, particularly for businesses anticipating going into a lockdown ahead of events like the G20 summit.

A phone list – paper and ink, as anything electronic cannot be relied upon in an emegency - is also a mandatory part of a communication contingency.

Food and water are rarely in short supply in the heart of a major city – but just in case, it always helps to have some in a 72-hour kit no matter where you are.  However, just as important can be extra prescription and over the counter medications.  Ducking out to a drug store this weekend could have landed a person detained by riot police, if one were to be caught in the wrong place at the wrong time.

Likewise, a first aid kit is essential.  Ambulance services in some areas of the Toronto core were non-existent during the peak periods of protestor and police showdowns.  Street closures caused by large crowds made some roads impassable, and in any event, ambulance services will not place their members in jeopardy by having them drive into a riot.

A kit containing an inexpensive digital camera would be useful in documenting any damage done to one’s home or business, and may even assist authorities in identifying potential culprits at a later date.  Basic tools and materials can be used to patch up broken windows or doors, and make other minor repairs should an errant brick make its way through a ground-floor facade.

If the kit is at a downtown workplace, a supply of sleeping kit would be handy, if you or your employees expect to have to bed down for a night or two.  Reasonably priced sleeping bags are available at sporting goods stores, and army surplus stores sell cheap wool blankets that suit the task.

A radio – for public news and announcements – and even a pre-programmed radio scanner, are also handy information tools.  Scanning media, police, and fire frequencies allows you to gauge the proximity of any threats or incidents you need to be concerned about.  Manjor announcements and emergency directions will be made over mainstream media, such as radio or television.

It is not even a bad idea to have a supply of N95 and functional gas masks, in case police tear gas or pepper spray is deployed on your cafe patio, or near your building’s fresh air intake.

There is no one “72-hour kit” solution.  And having anything set aside for emergencies is better than having nothing set aside.  While it can be hard to judge ahead of time whether your home or business will be in a potential risk area, particularly with fluid protest actions such as this past weekends’, the value of having performed some emergency planning ahead of time cannot be overstated.

When the rioters come past your door, it is already too late to start your emergency planning.

Bookmark and Share

G20 Summit is Example of Layered Security Approach

Pedestrians are reflected in a glass building as they walk alone a security fence on Front Street in Toronto, Thursday, June 24, 2010, as the security fencing is in place around the Metro Toronto Convention Center for the upcoming G8 and G20 Summits. (AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster)

Pedestrians are reflected in a glass building as they walk alone a security fence on Front Street in Toronto, Thursday, June 24, 2010, as the security fencing is in place around the Metro Toronto Convention Center for the upcoming G8 and G20 Summits. (AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster)

A perfect example of a layered, or “onion”, approach to security planning is presently on display at the G8 and G20 Summits being held in Huntsville and Toronto, respectively.

The layered approach is often advocated in CTPED (crime prevention through environmental design) textbooks, and is a familiar concept to security industry experts and practitioners.

A strict CTPED approach involves strategies for access control within the built environment, and express use and maintenance of the “protected space”.   An access control strategy incorporates the ability to provide for natural surveillance of one’s surroundings, defined points of entry and access control measures, and territorial reinforcement.

The G20 Summit will be held in the heart of Canada’s largest urban centre, necessitating an artificial “built” environment to augment the existing one.  And, as various media and the Integrated Security Unit in charge of security have reported, that artificial environment – namely a security fence estimated at 6 km in total length – is quite large.

In fact, there are two fences, which reinforced another CTPED concept – that of “defensible space”.   In security circles, this is also referred to as “sterile space”.  The area between the outer fence and the inner fence is sterile in the sense that severe access restrictions have been placed on those wishing to enter.

Most will require pre-registration or accreditation, and for the most part include media, policing and security authorities, and attending delegates.  The ISU has said that members of the public who show identification and have a valid need to enter will be permitted to do so, depending on the current security situation.  Since the outer perimetre includes several hotels, a residential condominium building, and the CBC building, it is likely that unregistered members of the public would be heading to one of those locations, potentially with an escort.

The concept at the outer perimeter is to isolate any threats that manage to make it past that perimeter.  The inner area is blanketed with surveillance – again reinforcing a CTPED concept, that of “natural surveillance”.  The size of the secure zone requires CCTV, and as has been reported, there is plenty of it: 77 additional CCTV cameras in all.

The inner fence, it can be expected is strictly off limits to anyone but particular media, delegates and security personnel.  This again reinforces the CTPED concept of territorial reinforcement by restricting private activities to clearly defined private areas.

We see from the G20 Summit example that the security measures known and announced to be in place are in reality no different than what a security consultant, service provider, or even community police officer would recommend for a private residence, retail shopping mall, residential high-rise or commercial property – just scaled up to meet the particular needs of a major international event.

Applying a layered security approach is not just for heads of state. 

Applying a layered security approach is not just for heads of state.  A residence can be adapted to provide natural surveillance by curtailing shrubs that obscure windows, and a lawn mowed weekly reinforces territorial use.

A coffee shop posting a sign that limits customer visits to 20 minutes provides notice that follow access control principles straight out of a CTPED manual.  The policy doesn’t even need to be enforced rigourously to provide a psychological message to undesireable elements that their presence is not welcome.

Bookmark and Share

Three Arrested in RBC Bombing

A fire erupts at an Ottawa RBC branch in an image posted to ottawa.  Three arrests have been made in connecction with this arson.

A fire erupts at an Ottawa RBC branch in an image posted to ottawa. Three arrests have been made in connecction with this arson.

Ottawa police reported Saturday the arrests of three men in connection with the May 18 fire bombing of an RBC branch that caused $500,000 in damage.

The fire bombing was allegedly videotaped by the suspects and posted to an anti-capitalist website the same day, along with a message that the perpetrators would be present at the upcoming G8/G20 summits in Huntsville and Toronto.

Charged with arson, explosives offences, and mischief are Roger Clement, 58, and Matthew Morgan-Brown, 32, both of Ottawa, and charged with fail to comply and possession of ammunition is Claude Haridge, 50, also of Ottawa.

Morgan-Brown was also reportedly arrested in 2007 following a demonstration at Ottawa’s ritzy Chateau Laurier hotel, held just prior to the Montebello summit. 

Both Morgan-Brown and Clement also appear on a web list of supporters for Algerian Mohamed Harkat, an alleged sleeper agent for Al-Qaeda who was previously detained on a security certificate in Canada, and who remains under house arrest in Ottawa awaiting deportation.  On that list of supporters, Morgan-Brown identified as association with the Catapult! collective, and a “Matthew Morgan” has in the past been a frequent contributor to the same website where the RBC fire bombing video was first posted.

Charges were also laid against Clement and Haridge by Ottawa police in relation to an earlier incident where another Ottawa RBC branch was damaged, using rocks and a hammer.

According to police, the ammunition Haridge allegedly possessed illegally was 7.62mm, which is a common military calibre used for light and medium machineguns.  The ammunition is also available to civilian markets, usually referred to as .308 calibre.

All the accused men had bail hearings Saturday and were remanded.  They will appear again in court later this month.

Ottawa police said they were assisted by Ontario Provincial Police and the RCMP in the investigation.  Media reports have also said that the three men were under police surveillance not long after the bank bombing.

RBC branches across Canada have been targeted numerous times in recent months by anti-capitalism and other groups, in the lead up to the Vancouver Olympics and to the G8 and G20 summits.

Bookmark and Share